If you’re looking to make the most of your camping trip, it’s important to choose the right tent fabric to fit your needs.
Are you on a budget, or is the sky the limit? Will you be going it alone, or is your family coming along for the ride? What sort of environment and weather are you expecting? These are all key things to consider before taking on an expedition.
With so many tent fabric choices out there, it’s understandable for campers to be at a loss. If you’re experiencing some option paralysis, fear not — Able Camper has you covered.
We’ve compiled a list of the primary tent fabric options, breaking them down based on their advantages and drawbacks. So strap up, and let’s get into some of the main differences between tent fabrics.
Nylon tents are a common choice for campers since they offer a host of attractive qualities at an affordable rate. Here are some key pros and cons to consider.
Benefits of Nylon Tents
- Cost-Efficiency: Nylon tents are affordable and come with a considerable bang for your buck. They’re among the most cost-efficient tents on the market — however, nylon fabrics with additional protective coatings come at a higher price tier depending on the strength of coating added.
- Convenience: Aside from being a breeze to maintain, Nylon tents are easy to pack, and their low packed volume makes them convenient to store.
- Lightweight: Nylon is a light material compared to most other tent fabrics. This ensures a minimal carry weight for the tent.
- Water-Resistant Options: Applied coatings allow nylon tents some extent of water resistance. A silicone coating is recommended to maximize a nylon tent’s waterproofing attributes.
Drawbacks of Nylon Tents
- Low UV Resistance: Nylon tents are typically vulnerable to damage from ultraviolet light. It’s considered good practice to limit their exposure to direct sunlight.
- Susceptible to Tearing: It’s highly recommended for heavy-duty campers (hunters, hikers, etc.) to opt for Ripstop nylon since traditional nylon tents can tear easily. Their vulnerability to tearing makes nylon a great choice for small tents, but unsuitable for family-sized tents.
- Low Breathability: Nylon tents offer good strength for their price point, but this comes at the cost of low breathability.
Like their nylon counterparts, polyester tents are one of the more popular choices for campers, especially beginners on a budget. Let’s dive into some of the details.
Benefits of Polyester Tents
- Versatility: Polyester tents are available in a wide array of coatings which makes them ideal for a variety of weather conditions. They’re also applicable to tents of all sizes, from single dome tents to family camping tents.
- Tear Resistance: Thanks to the inherent strength and malleability of the fabric, polyester tents aren’t as vulnerable to tears as their nylon counterparts.
- Price: Polyester tents are typically found at the lower end of the price spectrum.
Drawbacks of Polyester Tents
- Condensation: Their low breathability makes polyester tents susceptible to condensation.
- Lifespan: Since polyester tents tend to be in the lower tier of tent fabric quality, they typically don’t last very long compared to pricier fabrics.
- Low Heat and UV Resistance: Similar to nylon, polyester fabric can be weakened when exposed to direct sunlight. It can also be damaged when left standing for long periods of time in hot weather.
Cotton Canvas Tents
Cotton canvas tents are a strong, timeless alternative, having been relied on for several generations of experienced campers. Before jumping into the welcoming embrace of a cotton canvas tent, consider the following.
Benefits of Cotton Canvas Tents
- Comfort: Cotton canvas tents are known to allow a great degree of comfort under various climates, providing warmth in winter while being quite cool in the summertime.
- Breathability/Water-Resistance: Thanks to their reliable composition, cotton canvas tents expand and swell in order to self-seal against rain. This makes it difficult for water to penetrate through its pores — however, it’s important for the tent to be adequately weathered before use.
- UV Resistance: Campers can rest easy knowing that their cotton canvas tents come with a high degree of UV resistance.
- Lifespan: With proper care and maintenance, cotton canvas tents can last for years of frequent use before they need to be replaced.
Drawbacks of Cotton Canvas Tents
- Hard Work: Cotton canvas tents bring a lot of benefits to a campsite, but that comes at the cost of labor. Due to their significant weight and bulk, these tents require a good amount of elbow grease to put up, pack up, and transport.
- Vulnerable to Mildew: Although the material is tough compared to its competition, cotton canvas is notoriously susceptible to mildew.
- Maintenance: Campers are required to do regular maintenance to get the most out of their cotton canvas tents in the long run.
- Price: All the advantages attributed to cotton canvas tents don’t come cheap. They’re commonly priced at the higher tier of tent fabrics.
Polycotton Canvas Tents
A marriage of polyester and cotton canvas tents, polycotton canvas offers a host of advantages granted by the two halves of its whole.
Benefits of Polycotton Canvas Tents
- Best of Both Worlds: Polycotton canvas tents are a solid overall choice since they combine the best attributes of polyester and cotton canvas tents.
These tents fend off mildew better than cotton canvas, are generally UV and heat resistant while being transportable at a relatively low weight.
- Lifespan: Polycotton tents are well-formulated, and with the proper maintenance they can last for many years of regular use.
- Breathability: Its unique composition allows polycotton a fair degree of breathability, allowing it some resistance against condensation and moisture.
Drawbacks of Polycotton Canvas Tents
- Maintenance: These tents can potentially last a lifetime, but not without proper care and maintenance.
- Bulk: Although lighter than cotton canvas, polycotton canvas tents are still relatively bulky.
- Price: Due to their high-quality composition, polycotton canvas tents are commonly placed at the higher end of the tent fabric price spectrum.
Dyneema Composite Fabric Tents
Formerly known as Cuben Fiber, Dyneema Composite Fiber is a relatively new entry to the tent fabric world. There’s a lot of buzz surrounding this prime tent fabric contender, so let’s dive right into the details.
Benefits of Dyneema Composite Fabric Tents
- Ultra-Light: Dyneema Composite Fabric is even lighter than nylon — in fact, nylon tents typically weigh twice as much as Dyneema Composite Fabric tents.
- Super Strength: Pound for pound, Dyneema Composite Fabric is 15 times stronger than steel. Its formula allows it to be resistant to chemicals and ultraviolet light, and it won’t be torn as long as it isn’t subjected to excessive force during tent installation.
- Waterproof: Dyneema Composite Fabric is inherently waterproof. Unlike cotton canvas, its waterproofing is achieved without the need to absorb water.
Drawbacks of Dyneema Composite Fabric Tents
- Very Expensive: Dyneema Composite Fabric tents are ideal for a wide array of outdoor applications, but — you guessed it — their convenience comes at an exceptional price tag. They are the most expensive tent fabric option by a long shot.
- Low Malleability: For all their incredible strengths, Dyneema Composite Fabric tents don’t come with any ‘play’. This means that special attention is necessary when erecting these tents since they aren’t made to stretch into the desired shape.
In extreme cases where campers use excessive force while putting them up, Dyneema Composite Fabric tents can be punctured despite their durability.
- No Heat Resistance: It’s not recommended for campers to prepare hot meals under a Dyneema Composite Fabric tent, since the formula doesn’t provide resistance to heat.
In the end, the right choice of tent fabric depends on your specific needs — mainly your budget, camping environment, and how you intend on spending your trip.
Keep in mind that we’ve covered the primary differences between tent fabrics, but the quality may vary depending on the manufacturer and the type of coating being applied.
It’s best to take your time, shop around, and if a liquidation sale on Dyneema Composite Fabric ever arises, definitely look into it!